During a recent roof project in Paterson, we had to decide whether to patch problem areas or replace the roof entirely — and hidden damage made the decision for us.
From the street, the roof didn’t look terrible. A few missing shingles, minor leaks inside. But once sections were opened, the decking told a different story.
Project snapshot:
Home type: 2-story single-family
Roof size: ~1,600 sq ft
Final choice: full asphalt shingle replacement
Total cost: ~$11,800
Cost comparison:
Targeted repairs: ~$4,200
Full replacement: ~$11,800
Why replacement was the smarter move:
Soft decking in multiple areas
Repairs would’ve been temporary
New roof came with warranty coverage
Local note:
Materials were supplied by a local Paterson roofing supplier, which helped speed up delivery and keep batches consistent.
Takeaway:
If decking is compromised, repairs only delay the real cost. Opening up the roof early avoids paying twice.