During a recent flooring reno
vation in Hoboken, we had to choose between refinishing old hardwood or installing luxury vinyl plank (LVP) — and moisture risk ended up being the deciding factor.
The existing hardwood looked salvageable, but subfloor readings showed higher humidity near the exterior wall. Refinishing would’ve looked great short-term, but long-term movement was a concern.
Project snapshot:
Area: 800 sq ft apartment
Final choice: Luxury vinyl plank
Total cost: ~$6,400
Cost comparison:
Hardwood refinish: ~$4,900
LVP materials + install: ~$6,400
Why LVP made more sense here:
Better moisture tolerance
Faster install with fewer surprises
Lower maintenance for rental use
Local sourcing note:
LVP was sourced from Floor & Decor (Secaucus) — consistent batches and decent underlayment options.
Takeaway:
Cheaper upfront doesn’t always mean safer long-term. Flooring choices depend on moisture, use, and building type — not just appearance.