Gutter guard vs leaf filter?

What is the difference between gutter guard and leaf filter?

Gutter guards and leaf filters are both designed to keep debris out of your gutters, but they function differently.

Gutter guards usually sit on top of the existing gutters and allow water to flow while blocking larger debris. They come in various designs, such as mesh or solid surfaces. On the other hand, leaf filters are integrated systems that often replace your gutters entirely, featuring a built-in filtration system that can handle smaller debris, including pine needles.

Key Differences:

  • Installation: Gutter guards can often be added to existing gutters, while leaf filters typically require a complete gutter replacement.
  • Cost: Leaf filters tend to be more expensive, ranging from $2,500 to $7,000, compared to gutter guards which can cost between $3,600 and $16,000 depending on the brand and installation.
  • Effectiveness: Leaf filters generally provide better filtration against smaller debris, while gutter guards can be effective for larger leaves.

Tip: When considering renovations for your home, evaluate your local environment. If you have many trees, investing in a more comprehensive system like a leaf filter may save you maintenance costs in the long run. Always consult with local communities or forums for personal experiences and recommendations.