St. John's — Top 5 Renovation Picks (Aug 09, 2025)

11 Garrison Hill — $300,000

  • Beds/Baths/Sqft: 3 bd / 2 ba / 2,511 sqft
  • Price per SqFt: $119
  • Year Built / Type: — / Single Family Residential
  • Summary: This turn-of-the-20th-century home retains its authentic character with high ceilings and original features, making it a unique renovation opportunity.
  • Renovation rationale:
    • Low price per square foot at $119, providing significant upside potential.
    • Located in a historic area, which may appeal to buyers looking for charm and character.
  • Why these metrics matter for renovation:
    • The low price per sqft allows for a larger renovation budget while maintaining a favorable ARV (after repair value) in a desirable neighborhood.
  • Recommended renovation ideas:
    • Update the kitchen and bathrooms to modern standards while preserving original architectural features.
    • Enhance outdoor space for better usability.
  • View on Redfin

39 Roche St — $375,000

  • Beds/Baths/Sqft: 3 bd / 2 ba / 2,128 sqft
  • Price per SqFt: $176
  • Year Built / Type: — / Single Family Residential
  • Summary: Located in a desirable area, this charming home features a mature lot and is close to amenities, presenting a solid renovation opportunity.
  • Renovation rationale:
    • Reasonable price per square foot at $176, allowing for potential renovations to increase value.
    • Backing onto Larch Park, providing a serene environment.
  • Why these metrics matter for renovation:
    • The established neighborhood and reasonable price per sqft can lead to a solid return on investment through strategic renovations.
  • Recommended renovation ideas:
    • Modernize the kitchen and bathrooms for higher appeal.
    • Enhance outdoor living space to take advantage of the park views.
  • View on Redfin

28 Bambrick St — $325,000

  • Beds/Baths/Sqft: 3 bd / 1.5 ba / 1,560 sqft
  • Price per SqFt: $208
  • Year Built / Type: — / Single Family Residential
  • Summary: This semi-detached home is well cared for and features a large corner lot, making it ideal for families and investors alike.
  • Renovation rationale:
    • The price per square foot at $208 is competitive for the area, offering room for upgrades.
    • The corner lot provides additional space for outdoor improvements.
  • Why these metrics matter for renovation:
    • The combination of a reasonable price per sqft and usable lot size can enhance rental income potential or resale value after renovations.
  • Recommended renovation ideas:
    • Update the kitchen and bathrooms to modernize the home.
    • Consider landscaping enhancements to improve curb appeal.
  • View on Redfin

55 Field St — $150,000

  • Beds/Baths/Sqft: 3 bd / 2 ba / 1,455 sqft
  • Price per SqFt: $103
  • Year Built / Type: — / Single Family Residential
  • Summary: This two-apartment home is located in a prime area, ideal for investors or first-time buyers looking for rental income.
  • Renovation rationale:
    • Extremely low price per square foot at $103, providing a significant opportunity for value-add renovations.
  • Why these metrics matter for renovation:
    • The low entry price enables a larger renovation budget, enhancing potential rental income or resale value.
  • Recommended renovation ideas:
    • Update the interior finishes and appliances to attract higher rental rates.
    • Improve energy efficiency with modern systems.
  • View on Redfin

99 Freshwater Rd — $369,900

  • Beds/Baths/Sqft: 5 bd / 2.5 ba / 2,650 sqft
  • Price per SqFt: $140
  • Year Built / Type: — / Single Family Residential
  • Summary: This beautifully preserved home combines historic charm with modern convenience, making it a versatile renovation opportunity.
  • Renovation rationale:
    • The price per square foot at $140 offers a great entry point for a larger home with renovation potential.
  • Why these metrics matter for renovation:
    • The spacious layout and low price per sqft allows for significant renovations that can increase both rental and resale values.
  • Recommended renovation ideas:
    • Restore original features while modernizing key areas like the kitchen and bathrooms.
    • Create an outdoor space that enhances the property’s appeal.
  • View on Redfin

1 Like

The last house is beautiful :heart_eyes:

The first house feels like the freaking White House :joy:

The natural environment around the second house :heart: